Friday, February 27, 2026

Neil Sedaka (1939-2026), "Oh, Carol" - a teenage trauma resolved through songwriting


Neil Sedaka, who died today at 86, was a prominent contributor to the soundtrack of my adolescence. From 1959 through 1960 he had a series of catchy pop hits that were staples on the radio and at James Monroe Junior High School dances. One of these, "Oh! Carol" (1959, clip above) was inspired by his own adolescent trauma. He dated a classmate at Abraham Lincoln High School, Brooklyn, named Carol Klein. It seems the relationship ended unhappily. She, later known to the world as Carole King, along with her husband Gerry Goffin, wrote a joking reply song, "Oh, Neil"

Today, Carole King posted a tribute to Neil Sedaka, noting that he had inspired her to become a songwriter.